|
|
|
|
The Two Voices of Job |
| Section: BOOK WORLD / FEATURED BOOK: Stephen Mitchell's The Book of Job |
| Author: Lonnie D. Kliever |
| Publication:
The World & I Online |
| Issue Date: 12/1/1987 |
| Size: 5,338 Words, 30,631 Characters |
|
Stephen Mitchell's The Book of Job is a welcome contribution to contemporary theological discussion. Though offered as a new English translation and poetic rendering of the Hebrew verse of Job, this thoughtful reading is a theological work through and through. Like any good theological interpretation of biblical materials, Mitchell treats the ancient text as a palimpsest, erasing here and rearranging there while fashioning a contemporary restatement of the biblical author's religious questions and answers. To be sure, Mitchell remains true to the literary structure and linguistic philology of the biblical text. But he offers a breathtaking version of Job that pulses with modern moral outrage and spiritual insight. Moreover, lest we misread his translation, Mitchell provides an introduction (see excerpt, p. 346) that adumbrates the theological subtext for his rendition of the biblical text.
Focusing the problem of human suffering in "a post-Holocaust age," Mitchell gives us a Job who undergoes Zen-like spiritual transformation. Following the best of recent biblical scholarship, Mitchell draws both a literary and a theological distinction between Job's lengthy poetic body and its brief prose prologue and epilogue. The Job of the prologue is an upright but servile believer whose faith is put to the test by a capricious and petulant Deity. But the Job of the poem is an anguished and angry questioner of his undeserved suffering. Rejecting the explanations and exhortations of his orthodox "comforters," Job turns his full outrage against God, who finally answers Job's passionate harangue by revealing a universe completely beyond good and evil. Comforted rather than crushed by this overwhelming vision of beauty and dread, Job surrenders himself in near silence to the eternal dance of life and death.
While greatly admiring the poetic beauty and spiritual power of Mitchell's The Book of Job, I find it a less challenging and less comforting theology than life in this post-Holocaust world requires. The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse are riding roughshod over the earth, and their destruction is too terrible to accept, as Mitchell suggests, as "the blissful play of the Supreme Lord." Purchasing the comfort of a serene world through a metaphysical sublimation that joins creativity and destructiveness on the same continuum is too high a price to pay. Escaping the challenge of a better world through a metaphysical evasion that accords good and evil equal standing in the universe - as Mitchell invites us to do - is too easy a life to buy. Being told by Mitchell that "the world of starving children and nuclear menace" is very good is no more acceptable than being told by John Calvin that God sends evil and death to punish sin and teach righteousness. Neither the God who sends suffering for human betterment nor the God who embraces suffering in divine contentment stands up to the Tyranny, War, Famine and Pestilence that stalk our modern world. Such religions of redemptive suffering do not take adequat...
Read Full Article
...rivializing its tragedy. For Job, nothing in heaven will ever redeem the human condition, but nothing on earth can ever exhaust the human prospect. Human sufferings and human satisfactions are as inseparable as they are inexhaustible. Holding those twin fates in balance without concealing life's absurdity or relinquishing life's heroism is human life's steepest challenge and deepest consolation.
(3,075 of 30,631 characters)
|
|
|
Publication Details
(The World & I Online) |
|
The World & I Online is a
comprehensive academic resource that encompasses a broad range of
articles by scholars and experts in the areas of Global Studies,
Liberal Arts, Fine & Applied Arts, General Science, and Spanish.
Originally published monthly in print as The World & I, our site
includes the complete contents since 1986 and continues to publish
a new issue online each month. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
